Why Emotionally Effective Leadership Is the Foundation of High-Performing Teams

Posted in Emotional Intelligence, Insights, Motivational, News

Emotionally effective leadership is no longer a “nice-to-have”; it is a defining driver of results, relationships, and resilient teams. Leaders who apply emotional intelligence lead with clarity, connection, and purpose, balancing performance with compassionate leadership. In today’s complex workplace, effective leadership requires more than strategy; it requires the ability to understand emotions, manage behaviour, and positively influence how people show up and work together.


Emotionally Effective Leadership: Mastering Emotions for Leadership Excellence

Research consistently shows that emotionally effective leadership is a measurable driver of engagement, trust, retention, and performance. Leaders with strong emotional intelligence are better equipped to navigate complexity, manage pressure, and create environments where people and results thrive.

Marshall Connects article, "Why Emotionally Effective Leadership Is the Foundation of High-Performing Teams"

A 2024 Harvard Business Review analysis confirms that leaders who demonstrate self-awareness, empathy, and emotional regulation are significantly more effective at building trust and leading through uncertainty. These capabilities are no longer optional; they are foundational to modern leadership effectiveness.

Further reinforcing this, McKinsey & Company reports that emotionally and socially skilled leaders are far more likely to lead high-performing teams, particularly during periods of change and disruption, which increasingly define today’s workplace. Gallup research adds that managers account for up to 70% of the variance in employee engagement, with emotionally intelligent leadership behaviours playing a critical role in reducing burnout and turnover.

Despite this compelling evidence, many leaders remain unaware of just how vital emotional intelligence is to their success or of the profound impact it has on relationships, culture, and the organization’s bottom line.

As Daniel Goleman famously noted:

“The most effective leaders are all alike in one crucial way…they all have a high degree of what has come to be known as emotional intelligence.” – Daniel Goleman, Harvard Business Review

What Emotional Intelligence Looks Like in Effective Leadership

At its core, emotional intelligence in leadership is about understanding emotions, your own and those of others and using that awareness to lead effectively. Emotionally intelligent leaders can remain composed under pressure, make thoughtful decisions, and communicate with clarity and purpose.

Leaders who master emotional effectiveness recognize how their emotions influence behaviour, tone, and decision-making. They are skilled at self-regulation, allowing them to respond rather than react, especially in challenging or high-stakes situations. According to Harvard Business Review, emotional self-regulation and empathy are among the strongest predictors of perceived leadership credibility and effectiveness.

By leading with emotional intelligence, leaders build trust, strengthen relationships, and create the psychological safety necessary for teams to perform at their best. Emotional effectiveness is not about avoiding difficult conversations; it is about approaching them with awareness, intention, and respect.

Do You Walk the Talk?

Being a positive role model and leading by example is foundational to emotionally effective leadership. Leaders who consistently “walk the talk” create psychological safety, an essential condition for team success. Google’s long-running Project Aristotle continues to show that psychological safety is the number one predictor of team effectiveness, and emotionally intelligent leadership behaviours are key to creating it.

Leaders who practice compassionate leadership, by listening actively, responding thoughtfully, and managing their emotions, foster healthier, more productive workplaces. These environments encourage collaboration, accountability, and innovation, all hallmarks of high-performance teams and emotional intelligence.

My Experience with Emotionally Effective Leadership Is Extensive

Throughout my career, I have worked under many leaders, some far more effective than others. Regardless of their leadership style, each experience offered valuable lessons. The leaders who influenced me most were those with high emotional intelligence. I watched them self-regulate during difficult moments, “read the room” in tense situations, and adapt their approach as circumstances changed.

What makes emotional intelligence in leadership so powerful is that it can be learned and strengthened over time. Research confirms that EI development leads to improved leadership effectiveness, stronger relationships, and better outcomes (Cornell University, 2025). Training leaders in leadership emotional intelligence training not only supports individual growth but also creates a positive ripple effect across teams and entire organizations.

What Qualities Do Emotionally Intelligent Leaders Have?

Leaders with advanced emotional intelligence demonstrate strong self-awareness, social awareness, empathy, and compassion. Emotional intelligence is often referred to as “the other kind of smart” and remains one of the strongest predictors of both personal and professional success.

Think of someone who is academically brilliant but struggles socially. Without emotional intelligence, even the most technically skilled individuals may fail to build trust or lead dynamic teams. Research consistently shows that emotionally intelligent leaders are more successful at relationship-building, conflict management, and sustained performance (Gallup, 2025).

Importantly, compassionate leadership is not about being “nice” or avoiding difficult conversations. It is about being aware of how we relate to others, reflecting on our behaviour, and adjusting when necessary. Compassion and accountability are not opposites; they are partners.

How Does Leading with Emotional Intelligence Differentiate Leaders?

Emotionally effective leadership differentiates leaders through their ability to recognize, understand, and manage emotions, both their own and those of others. Leaders with high EI consistently outperform peers in communication, adaptability, and decision-making.

Leaders with high EI:

  • Communicate more effectively by tailoring their approach to emotional cues, improving clarity and collaboration (McKinsey, 2021).

  • Demonstrate empathy, helping employees feel valued, heard, and understood, key drivers of engagement and retention (Gallup, 2025).

  • Navigate conflict calmly and constructively to prevent escalation and preserve trust.

  • Regulate their emotions to enable sound judgment and consistent leadership under pressure.

  • Inspire motivation by connecting work to values and purpose, strengthening commitment and performance.

  • Adapt more effectively to change, helping teams remain resilient during uncertainty.

  • Build cohesive teams by leveraging diverse strengths and personalities.

  • Proactively address emotional signals to prevent issues before they become disruptive.

These capabilities are foundational to high-performance teams and to EQ, and they directly influence organizational outcomes.

How Can You Build a Team of Emotionally Intelligent Leaders?

According to the Human Capital Institute, emotional intelligence assessments are among the most cost-effective tools for leadership development. Sixty percent of organizations that use EI assessments rate them as effective or very effective. Additional high-impact development methods include executive coaching, job rotations, and global assignments.

To build an emotionally intelligent leadership team, I recommend three practical steps:

  1. Provide leaders with an EQ-i 2.0® Leadership Self-Assessment

  2. Use assessment results as a targeted developmental roadmap

  3. Invest in leadership emotional intelligence training, such as our EI Effectiveness Leadership Academy

Research consistently shows that intentional EI development improves leadership effectiveness, employee engagement, and organizational resilience (Gallup, 2025).

Emotionally effective leadership is what transforms managers into trusted leaders and groups into high-performing teams. By strengthening emotional intelligence, leaders cultivate influence, resilience, and compassionate connection, especially during moments of challenge and change.

Undoubtedly, an emotionally effective leader skillfully guides their team to success. Their ability to connect on an emotional level sets them apart from average leaders and builds An emotionally effective leader does more than direct work; they build trust, elevate engagement, and create environments where people feel valued and motivated to perform at their best. When leadership is grounded in emotional intelligence, communication improves, collaboration deepens, and organizational culture strengthens. If you’re ready to grow your impact as a leader, developing emotional intelligence through assessment, coaching, or training can help you lead with greater confidence, compassion, and effectiveness for yourself, your team, and your organization.


This article was originally published on October 12, 2018, and has been updated (February 2026).

More Motivational Reads Here »


How Emotionally Intelligent Are You?

Sign up for Linda’s monthly tips to build your Emotional Intelligence and reduce Emotional Hijacking!


How Emotionally Intelligent Are You?

Sign up now for monthly tips to build your Emotional Intelligence and reduce Emotional Hijacking!

We’re proud to say we’ve done some wonderful work with some wonderful community-minded organizations.

  • Pearson Dunn Insurance Inc.

  • Budds' BMW Hamilton

  • Hamilton Arts Council

  • Hamilton Philharmonic Orchestra

  • Mohawk College

  • OBIA

  • Physique Fitness

  • WEAVA

  • McMaster University - Student Success Centre

  • Hamilton Family Health Team

  • AllerGen
  • Marshall Truck & Trailer Repair Ltd.
  • Nielsen
  • PCL Construction
  • Royal Bank
  • Wesley Urban Ministries
  • North Hamilton Community Health Centre